Barbara Benefiel Elder, 88, of Tulsa, Oklahoma, died July 23. She was born September 3, 1931, in Coffeyville, Kansas. She began taking piano lessons at age 5 and played her first solo recital at age 13, receiving musical honors during her school years in Coffeyville. Benefiel graduated summa cum laude in 1953 from Hastings College, Nebraska, with a Bachelor of Arts degree, the second person to graduate with a 4.00 average in the history of the college. She earned a Master of Music degree from the University of Tulsa with a 4.00 average in 1960.